What is the most important consideration before evaluating an after-dinner speech or commencement address?

In evaluating an after-dinner speech or commencement address, understanding genre and cultural expectations is crucial. These types of speeches have distinct purposes and audience expectations that fundamentally shape how they should be delivered and received. For instance, an after-dinner speech is typically meant to entertain while also conveying a message, often infused with humor and a light-hearted tone. A commencement address, on the other hand, is usually serious, motivational, and reflective, addressing themes such as achievement, future endeavors, and life lessons.

Considering genre and cultural expectations allows the evaluator to assess whether the speaker effectively aligned with the audience's anticipations. This understanding provides a foundation for evaluating the speech's content, delivery, and overall impact, as cultural context can significantly influence how messages are interpreted. Thus, grounding the evaluation in these considerations leads to a more nuanced understanding of the speech's effectiveness and resonance with the audience.